New York Court Upholds Denial Of Workers’ Compensation Claim For PTSD

A person is allowed to file a workers’ compensation claim for not only physical injuries but mental harm as well. However, proving that a worker suffered mental harm that exceeded ordinary levels of stress is not easy. Unlike physical injuries, mental injuries cannot be seen on X-rays, so claims are hard to get approved.
A New York appellate court has upheld the denial of workers’ compensation benefits to a train conductor who developed post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) after learning that a passenger had fallen onto the tracks and was fatally struck by another train. The court concluded that, under the law in effect at the time, the incident did not expose the conductor to stress beyond what other train conductors could reasonably expect to experience on the job.
The case is known as the Matter of Williams v. New York City Transit Authority, No. CV-24-0860 (N.Y. App. Div. June 11, 2026). In this case, the train conductor filed a workers’ compensation claim, alleging that the fatal accident caused him to develop PTSD. Initially, a workers’ compensation law judge approved the claim.
On administrative review, however, the New York Workers’ Compensation Board reversed that decision. The board determined that the emotional stress associated with the incident was not greater than the stress normally encountered by similarly situated train conductors during the course of their work. As a result, the board concluded that the event did not qualify as a compensable workplace accident under New York’s workers’ compensation law and denied benefits. The conductor appealed the ruling but the Appellate Division affirmed the workers’ compensation board’s denial of benefits.
There was substantial evidence supporting the board’s decision. Testimony showed that train conductors understand there is an inherent possibility that a train may strike a person. The conductor also acknowledged that this was not his first experience with such an incident, having previously been involved in two other fatal or serious train strikes.
At the time of the incident, New York law required employees seeking compensation for work-related psychological injuries to prove two separate elements:
- The injury resulted from an accident.
- The injury arose out of and during the course of employment.
For mental health claims caused by workplace stress, courts considered the injury “accidental” only if the employee demonstrated that the emotional stress exceeded what similarly situated workers ordinarily experience in their normal work environment.
A person getting hit by a train is a recognized occupational risk for train conductors. The court concluded that the stress the conductor experienced was not out of the ordinary.
Contact Us for More Information About Workers’ Compensation Benefits
Proving mental health claims under state workers’ compensation law can be tricky. Some jobs are generally more stressful than others, so determining a threshold can be complicated for courts.
If you have been physically or mentally harmed while at work, contact a White Plains workers’ compensation lawyer from The Law Office of Michael Lawrence Varon. There are strict requirements and numerous hoops to jump through, but we can assist you in getting the compensation you need. Schedule a consultation today by calling (914) 228-1770 or filling out the online form.
Source:
workerscompensation.com/daily-headlines/death-of-passenger-constituted-normal-work-stress-for-nyc-conductor/
